Since Trump’s return, federal immigration agents have fired on civilians repeatedly, raising concerns over enforcement tactics.
There have been at least 16 shooting incidents by federal agents in the previous year, including the murder of Renee Good in Minneapolis last week when an Immigration and Customs Enforcement officer fired three shots into her car at close range, striking her in the face and igniting protests around the country.
Rubber bullets, pepper balls, and chemical sprays are just a few of the riot control weapons that have been used, often at close range. In at least 15 additional instances, federal immigration police have held people at gunpoint without firing.
Thousands of officers are still being added to locations that are primarily controlled by Democrats, thus the Trace's study and an analysis of federal numbers likely reflect an undercount.
“This makes us all less safe,”
according to gun
control advocacy group Everytown for Gun Safety.
“Armed intimidation in our communities does not make anyone safer,”
added Brady, a nonprofit organization against gun violence.
“More firearms in neighborhoods already impacted by gun violence helps no one. Police violence is gun violence.”
The most recent federal statistics show that 20 persons were killed by immigration police in 2023 and 2022. According to federal data, ICE and border patrol officers, the organizations responsible for the Trump administration's most recent round of federal law enforcement actions used lethal force against 19 individuals during that period, while a Coast Guard member was accountable for one death.
According to ICE's annual report, the internal guns and use of force committee looked at three instances in which an officer used a firearm during the 12 months ending in September 2024.
A 2024 investigation by The Trace, Type Investigations, and Business Insider found that ICE agents were accountable for 59 shootings during the six-year period between 2015 and 2022.
The first fatal shooting by immigration officials in the second Trump administration occurred in September when Silverio Villegas Gonzalez, a 38-year-old Mexican parent and cook, was shot at "close range" while reportedly attempting to escape ICE officers during a traffic check in Chicago.
According to the agency, a border patrol officer in Rio Grande City, Texas, shot a 31-year-old Mexican national three times last month while attempting to apprehend him. About an hour after the incident was reported, he was declared dead.
In Los Angeles, California, an off-duty ICE agent shot and killed 43-year-old Keith Porter on New Year's Eve.
Porter, a father of two, was apparently celebrating the New Year by firing a firearm into the air.
A few days prior, an American citizen in Los Angeles was shot in the shoulder by an immigration officer. Carlos Jimenez's attorneys claim that he warned the officers to leave the area because youngsters would shortly be there. He allegedly accelerated his vehicle in the direction of an officer while attempting to escape, according to federal authorities.
According to a Wall Street Journal study, immigration agents have fired on moving cars at least thirteen times in the past year. Administration officials have defended these measures against drivers who have "weaponized" their vehicles against law enforcement.
“When faced with dangerous circumstances, DHS law enforcement used their training to protect themselves, their fellow officers, and the public,”
Homeland Security spokeswoman Tricia McLaughlin told the
newspaper.
Officers are not allowed to fire at a moving car unless "no other objectively reasonable means of defense appear to exist," according to Department of Justice guidelines.
“Everything about these incidents indicates that these are probably shootings that did not need to happen,”
Georgetown Law
professor and former Department of Justice litigator Christy Lopez told The
Trace.
Although the majority of recent shooting occurrences took place in the Chicago and Los Angeles regions, a number of them, including Good's murder, happened in and near Minneapolis.
An ICE officer opened fire on a guy in an SUV in St. Paul, Minnesota, late last month after the driver allegedly hit two officers with his vehicle. The driver did not sustain any injuries.
Additionally, the same ICE officer who shot and killed Good was hurt when he used a Taser on a driver during a traffic check in June. According to his testimony, the officer, Jonathan Ross, shot Roberto Carlos Muñoz ten times with his Taser after smashing the rear driver's side window and witnessing "the impacts on his face."
“I was fearing for my life. I knew I was going to get drug [sic],”
Ross said.
“And the fact I couldn’t get my arm out, I didn’t know how long I would be drugged. So I was kind of running with the vehicle.”
According to prosecutors, Ross claimed he was pulled over 100 yards and had 20 stitches for a cut on his right arm and 13 stitches on his left hand.
Muñoz, however, made it through the meeting. He was later found guilty by a jury of assault with a deadly and dangerous weapon and causing bodily harm.
What training changes DHS has proposed since these reports?
DHS has not blazoned specific training changes for immigration officers in response to recent firing reports as of January 14, 2026.
DHS defends all 13 vehicle- related discharges since July 2025 as justified" tone- defense against weaponized vehicles," with internal affairs reviews citing agents' comprehension of imminent pitfalls during hobbies. No policy shifts or retraining authorizations appear in public statements, despite calls from Egalitarians and ACLU forde-escalation protocols amid 40 use- of- force rises.
Post-2020 George Floyd uneasiness, CBP enforced bodycam expansions and 8- hour use- of- force routines, but Trump's alternate term prioritises enforcement expansion over restraint CBP data shows periodic training unchanged at 160 hours, fastening Rules of Engagement rather than vehicle stop druthers like shaft strips or roadblocks.
-1768338309.webp&w=3840&q=75)